The Pros and Cons of Selling Your House Vs Renting It Out

Exploring Your Options: Selling A House or Renting It Out?

Hey there! If you're torn between the classic dilemma of "Should I sell my house or rent it out?" or thinking, "I want to sell my house and rent instead," you're not alone. It's a decision many homeowners face, balancing financial aspirations and housing needs. Let's explore the pros and cons to help you navigate this pivotal real estate crossroads.

Key Highlights 

  • Selling your house can release equity, eliminate landlord responsibilities, and capitalize on a hot seller's market.

  • Renting out your home can produce revenue, appreciate over time, and be a backup.

  • The decision depends on your finances, future ambitions, and market conditions.

Should I Sell My House or Rent It Out?

Which path should you choose as a homeowner? Should you consider renting it or selling it?

No single answer exists for this question. There's plenty to consider before deciding to sell or rent.

You must investigate, set financial and personal goals, crunch figures, and make tough decisions. First, the benefits and drawbacks of selling your house.

Editor Picks: How to Sell a House Quickly Without Losing Its Actual Cost?

Pros of Selling Your Property

Maximize your profits and explore the advantages of selling your property with expert guidance.

Access Instant Capital: 

Selling your house might release a sizable amount of cash immediately, which you can use to settle debts and make other investments.

Opt for the Simpler Path:

Selling your house is a one-time endeavour. It's gone as soon as you write it down. On the other hand, renting is a constant investment that needs regular care.

Cons of Selling Your Property

Discover the hidden downsides of selling your property and make an informed decision.

Lose Out on Huge Financial Gains: 

Three key reasons individuals rent out their (former) principal house are appreciation, income, and tax benefits. This position offers specific cash incentives depending on your property and rental market forecast. 

Experience a Loss: 

Now may be the wrong time to sell. If the market drops, you may lose money selling your home. COVID-19 shook the condo business and numerous significant markets.

Upfront Costs: 

Selling your property typically requires upfront costs for buyer-requested upgrades. Selling your home with a real estate agent might cost up to 6%. It's pricey.

Fail to Sell: 

Selling your property may be more difficult said than done, depending on your location and the condition of it. 

Must Read: What Are Mortgage Closing Costs? How Much Are Closing Expenses?

Pros of Renting Your Property

Learn why renting your property can be a smart financial move and reap the rewards of passive income.

Distinctive Investment Opportunity: 

Leasing your former primary house or other property may be an excellent investment. It offers advantages over equities, bonds, REITs, and others and can help diversify your portfolio. Advantages include appreciation, tax savings, income, volatility reduction, and leverage. 

Claim Tax deductions:

Renting your house can result in tax deductions for depreciation, mortgage interest, maintenance and advertising costs, and real estate management fees.

Boost Long-Term Income: 

By renting your house, you can find a renter who will pay your mortgage and potentially extra as your home appreciates. 

Get Consistent Income: 

Renting a home can give you lifetime income while selling your house will only generate one big payment.

Cons of Renting Your Property

Uncover the drawbacks of renting out your property and gain valuable insights.

Demands Time and Attention: 

Besides maintaining and promoting your rental, you must keep your renters pleased. If you don't have time, hire a property management company or utilize Nomad.

The Stock Market May Drop: 

There can be a crash in the housing market, which might be very unpleasant.

Having Trouble Getting a Second Mortgage:

Finding a lender to support your second mortgage may be difficult if you're making mortgage payments and don't have a large wage or down payment. If your home has a lot of equity, you may have inventive financing options. Nomad will connect you with a trustworthy lender to discuss your options.

Check Out: What Is the Average Cost of Living Index of Your City State?

Selling a House Vs Renting It Out

When moving, you may be able to sell or keep your current home. Real estate investors often opt to rent out their properties as a first step before selling.

Take these things into account if you're stuck.

Income vs. Down Payment

You'll need enough money for a down payment on your future home. Many individuals use the money from selling their previous property for the down payment, but if you want to keep the house as an investment, you'll need to find another approach. If you can accumulate enough cash for the down payment, holding on to a house as an investment could provide some monthly revenue.

If you've been there long enough or if your rentals eat up too little of your income, then yes, in the end, it all depends on how much money they gave back to a time when their lords had cattle but not cars. If you maintain the house as an investment, a home equity loan or line of credit might let you borrow against its worth. The equation's overall cost rises. 


It costs money to maintain a rental property. The majority of the upkeep and repairs around the house will fall under your budget while your tenants are paying you. You will incur additional costs for your new primary residence in addition to these. 

If you sell the house and move on, you just have to worry about such fees for one property. Your mortgage, property taxes, and insurance must be paid even when you're not renting. And your costs could go through the roof if the tenant breaks any property. Buyers' and real estate agents' commissions make selling a property expensive. 


Sell your home, skip the tax. Have you resided in the property for two years? Enjoy a tax deduction of $250,000 ($50,000 for couples) on your income tax returns! You will only pay a little tax if your proceeds are below the threshold. Renting your residence may help avoid taxes if your income exceeds the threshold. Remember that your landlord's income must be taxed yearly, subtracted from your costs. 


When turning your house into an investment property, you must manage it yourself or hire a property manager. Both conditions exclude setting up and forgetting about an investment property. Selling the house and avoiding renters may be best if your profit after property management fees is low. 

But if you are okay with the added labour, landlords could be worthwhile.


Or, if you are lucky enough to buy a new house but want some leeway, you can use the old one as temporary lodging rather than an investment property with long-term tenants. 

Listing the house on Airbnb or VRBO may improve your monthly revenue and allow you to use it as a vacation rental when not booked. Selling the home limits your flexibility. Your house might gain even more value throughout this period and when you sell it. 


Keeping your existing home loan on your credit record may make it harder to get a new one since it impacts your debt-to-income ratio. Refinancing the loan into the name of the property management firm may help. Still, it may be tricky if the company doesn't have credit. 

You may have to cosign the loan, hurting your credit. Additionally, that procedure can be expensive since closing costs are involved, and the interest rate on an investment property is usually greater than on a permanent dwelling.

Must Read: The Impact of Multiple Home Refinancing on Your Credit Score

How Would You Handle a Recession?

Some economists still believe the US will see a recession soon. Recent Bankrate Economic Indicator Polls predict a 46% risk of a recession by September 2024. Before selling or renting your house, consider how a major economic collapse will affect your finances. Is your employment secure? Are your savings substantial? In a recession, or if rental income was lower than anticipated, could you still afford two mortgages? Selling might be safer if any of these questions get a negative response.

Final Words

Consider whether the current scenario works for you and how it compares to alternative ways to get up before deciding to sell or rent your house. When choosing this significant, consider the direction in which house prices go. It would be best to weigh the costs involved in each option, your interest in becoming a landlord, and how soon you need to move back to where you came from.


How much profit should you make on a rental property?

An ideal rental property profit depends upon location, property type and market state. The past has shown us that an annual rate of return on investment between 6 % and 10 %, excluding costs such as upkeep, property taxes, etc., is usually considered reasonable.

Should I rent out my parents' house or sell it?

If you're thinking, "I want to sell my house and rent instead," consider your financial objectives and housing expectations. Selling provides immediate cash, but renting offers a continuous revenue stream with the chance of appreciation in property price. Before choosing, evaluate your long-term housing situation and talk to local real estate experts.

What is the rule of thumb for rental income? 

Generally, the rental income yield should be 1% of the monthly property value. For example, a $200,00 property would represent about $2, or monthly rent. However, local market conditions and property costs must also be considered when assessing tentative rental income.

Is it more profitable to rent or sell?

Whether to rent or sell is based on financial goals, property market conditions and long-term plans. Renting offers potential income and property appreciation, while selling provides immediate liquidity. Consult real estate experts to determine the best solution for your financial goals and circumstances.

Related Articles:

12 Feb, 2024


Add a comment

Why Is Tax Season Very Important for Stock Market Investors? |  Why Is There No Tax in UAE? How Dubai Makes Money with No Tax? |  Fastest Growing Industries in India 2024: Booming Indian Sectors |  Top Tech Companies List: Top 10 Largest Tech Giants Worldwide |